Note; This is such a multiple layered song and has been through SO MANY re-writes, I felt I needed to give it more attention or explanation.
Winter Tunes Tuesday
This song will be live on Spotify on Tuesday, Nov. 17 but you can find it on SoundCloud now.
What happens when you pray really hard—and God says NO?
You aren’t asking casually. You have prayed, waited, searched your heart, and tried to trust Him. The thing you want may even be a good thing.
And still, the door closes.
“A Mercy Severe” lives in that difficult place.
Alongside “Where the Might Have Beens All Hide,” - it may be my most complicated song. It brings together unanswered prayer, regret, fear, pride, and the unsettling possibility that grace is at work in circumstances I would never have chosen.
Of all the songs in my catalogue, this one has been given the most work- literally hours of re-writes.
I don’t always understand what God is doing. Sometimes faith means bringing that uncertainty into prayer—and staying there.
The phrase behind the title
The song’s title echoes a severe mercy, the phrase associated with C. S. Lewis’s correspondence with Sheldon Vanauken and the title of Vanauken’s 1977 memoir.
Vanauken and his wife, Davy, shared an intense love. They built what they called the “Shining Barrier,” protecting their relationship against anything that might pull them apart. During their Oxford years, friendship with Lewis helped lead them toward Christianity. But their conversion raised a difficult question: could their love make room for God to come first? After Davy’s death, that question became part of Vanauken’s struggle with grief.
In a letter, Lewis told him:
“You have been treated with a severe mercy.”
That is a hard story to sit with. We rarely know enough to tell a grieving person why something happened.
But Vanauken’s wrestling gives language to a question I recognize in my own life:
And of course beauty: the beauty that was for him the link between the ships and the woods and the poems. He remembered as though it were but a few days ago that winter night, himself too young even to know the meaning of beauty, when he had looked up at a delicate tracery of bare black branches against the icy glittering stars: suddenly something that was, all at once, pain and longing and adoring had welled up in him, almost choking him. He had wanted to tell someone, but he had no words, inarticulate in the pain and glory. Vanauken, Sheldon. A Severe Mercy: A Memoir of Marriage, Faith and Friendship with C.S. Lewis (p. 16). (Function). Kindle Edition.
Could God still be loving me when His answer hurts this much?
This song has older roots
Some of the background reaches back to my 2016 post, “The Gospel Confronts Addicts and Cynics.”
That reflection grew partly out of the influence of my friend Bill Delvaux: the heart can keep reaching for something to fill it, or become cynical and try to stop feeling altogether. One heart keeps demanding more; another builds defenses against disappointment. Both need the gospel.
Those two movements show up in the song. There is the road I was certain I needed to travel. Then there are the frozen walls built when life refuses to cooperate.
I built my walls with frozen stone,
Crowned myself, but ruled alone.
That last line is uncomfortable. I can insist on having my own way and then discover how lonely my little kingdom has become. It is interesting to me that I have now about 6 or 7 songs that all contain this idea of ruling alone in my own kingdom....
Although he was so far away across the sea, Lewis had been his mainstay in this half-year of sounding the depths of grief. He it was who had said that Davy’s death was a severe mercy. A severe mercy—the phrase haunted him: a mercy that was as severe as death, a death that was as merciful as love. For it had been death in love, not death of love. Love can die in many ways, most of them far more terrible than physical death; and if all natural love must die in one way or another, Davy’s death—he and she in love—was the death that hinted at springtime and rebirth.
Reading those words again, I can hear the beginnings of this song.
Why winter you ask? So I purposely sat down for a few weeks and contemplated winter- the time change- the darkness- the chill and I wrote some songs that delved into the purpose of this season- some of these songs are really dark... but they have a purpose.
Winter gives the song this landscape because it captures how this season feels.
A road disappears beneath the snow. Branches stand bare. The ground offers little evidence that anything will grow again.
When you are living through disappointment, the future can look like that. You remember what you expected to see. You struggle to imagine what could possibly come next.
The song begins there:
Winter fell where dreams once stood,
Bare branch prayers in frozen wood.
Even the prayers feel exposed.
But the second verse introduces a quieter movement:
Till grace moved in like thawing ground,
And hope learned how to make a sound.
I like that hope has to learn. Sometimes it returns hesitantly. You find yourself able to pray again. You receive a kindness. You begin to loosen your grip on the future you had demanded.
The landscape may still look like winter. Something is beginning to move.
The line I have to wrestle with
A mercy severe, that breaks but heals,
A love that wounds so hearts can feel.
Those are difficult words to sing honestly- but it comes straight out of Bill Delvaux's teaching- when the heart has become jaded or cynical- it becomes dead- and grieving is a type of healing- (sadly, it is why some people tormented with depression cut themselves- they just want to feel something).
Some pain comes from our own choices. Some comes from what others do. Some arrives without an explanation we can grasp. I cannot look at every wound and claim to know its purpose.
Yet I believe God can meet us in all of it. He can confront what is destroying us, restore what has grown cold, and bring life from ground we thought was finished.
When I speak of His discipline (Hebrews 12), I mean the care of a Father whose acceptance rests on Christ’s finished work. I do not have to earn my way back into His love through suffering.
And I do not have to call the pain pleasant to trust Him with it.
That is the tension in the chorus:
It’s the mercy I fear,
But it draws me near.
I want to grow, but I fear what change may require. I ask God to make me faithful while hoping He will leave certain comforts untouched.
This song lets that contradiction speak.
Fierce—but there
I took a risk making it a soft spoken line... but I wanted it to leap out of the ending.
The ending matters to me because it leaves us in the cold.
There is no sudden explanation for every disappointment. The road has not become completely visible. The singer has enough breath left to testify:
In the long night, the frozen air,
Your mercy remained—
Fierce… but there.
That is where I wanted to leave it.
I am still learning how to receive an answer I did not want. Still learning to bring regret into prayer without letting it have the final word. Still learning that I can trust God while admitting how little I understand.
For this week’s Winter Tunes Tuesday, the full lyrics belong here. The movement from frozen ground to the first sound of hope needs room to unfold.
“A Mercy Severe”
Verse 1
Winter fell where dreams once stood,
Bare branch prayers in frozen wood.
A road I swore was meant to be
Now disappears in white mystery.
Regret hangs heavy like a silent hymn,
But mercy calls through the northern wind.
Pre-Chorus
I’ve wrestled angels in the night,
Fire and smoke in pale moonlight.
When every comfort disappears,
There’s a mercy—fierce and near.
Chorus
A mercy severe, that breaks but heals,
A love that wounds so hearts can feel.
Through the cold, through the pain,
You shape my soul in snow and rain.
It’s the mercy I fear,
But it draws me near.
Verse 2
Fear’s cold hands around my chest,
Whispered lies I never confessed.
I built my walls with frozen stone,
Crowned myself, but ruled alone.
Till grace moved in like thawing ground,
And hope learned how to make a sound.
Pre-Chorus
The fields lie bare, the past undone,
Yet mercy waits beneath the sun.
Even loss has life to give
When mercy teaches us how to live.
Chorus
A mercy severe, that breaks but heals,
A love that wounds so hearts can feel.
Through the cold, through the pain,
You shape my soul in snow and rain.
It’s the mercy I fear,
But it draws me near.
Bridge
Every scar, every tear,
Counts the seasons I survived this year.
The pruning knife, the barren land,
Are still held in a faithful hand.
What looks like death, what feels unkind,
Is mercy working overtime.
Outro
A mercy severe, relentless, true,
It stripped me bare to make me new.
In the long night, the frozen air,
Your mercy remained—
Fierce… but there.











